Now all of them are angry, confused, scared, etc. They are talking of them being lies. They find a room in drawing room that had the gramophone with the record of their indictments. They began to wonder who played it. It was Mr. Rogers; he was ordered to play it by Mr. Owen by letter. He explains all of that to them. They all talk about everything and began to think Mr. Owen doesn't exist and if he does he is a mad man. They all think about everything and realize the boat is supposed to come back in the morning and are ready to leave. Anthony Marston tells them they should stay to try and figure everything out. As he is telling them that he chokes on his drink and dies. It was poisoned drink.